top of page
Welcome to the LOOP Antenna Community! Join and enjoy it!
We've been thinking of a community where we can all exchange ideas, opinions, or simply have a friendly chat about LOOP Antenna.
We rely on all members to help keep these discussion forums a safe place for people to share and view information.
So, please treat other community members the way you would like to be treated: be courteous and respectful, stay on topic, share your knowledge.
We will remove any post that includes personal attacks, swearing or offensive language, non-constructive criticism or falsehoods. Such a poor behavior will result in losing the community posting privileges. Thank you for your time and your help!
bottom of page
Hi, Craig,
They are certainly aware, because I had numerous communications with them on this subject. The last contact I had with them they were unable to replicate this in their lab, and were puzzling over this problem. As for the firmware, the latest for the ATU is 4.06, and this is the version that should be used with the serial switch. The problem would seem to be in the serial switch itself. You are correct, the function of the serial switch was to allow both a PC and the ATU to communicate with the radio at the same time so that logging programs, FT8 programs, etc, and the C-M ATU could all share access to the radio. In my case I used an Icom IC-7600, as well as my Elecraft KX3, and my Flex 6400M, all with the same result - the serial switch did not forward the communications from the PC to the radio, so that only the C-M frequency query commands were received by the radio. After a lot of investigation on my part C-M requested me to return my serial switch, and they eventually refunded my money despite the fact that I had said that I was quite prepared to await a replacement with updated firmware. I am not sure if the serial switch's firmware can be user updated like the C-M ATU. Having written this sort of software myself, I can well appreciate the technical problems. When I have had to do this professionally before I retired, I opted for a 'store and forward' algorithm so that you could interleave the various messages and responses and keep track of which message was destined for what device. This becomes even more challenging when attempting to communicate with an Icom radio using its CI-V interface as you now have to deal with a CDMA protocol, which will add further interest to the proceedings. It is certainly possible, but I suspect that C-M may well have to have a re-think as to how they are dealing with this in their serial switch. As I say, stay tuned...
Adrian 5B4AIY
Thanks Adrian, after a few days testing I came to the same conclusion. Let's hope they come up with a fix or I've wasted my money. I was under the impression that's what the switch was designed to do. If it's firmware it should be a simple fix. Maybe I should try rolling back the firmware? Is it worth emailing CM or are they aware and working on it?
Hi, Craig,
Unfortunately I had exactly the same problem. It did not matter what radio I used, nor what software I could not get a logging program to communicate with the radio via the serial switch. I placed a serial port analyser between the serial switch and the radio, and captured the data and found that no commands from the PC were being passed to the radio, the only commands were the frequency query commands from the ATU once every second. I captured the communications between both the PC and the serial switch, and between the serial switch and the radio and forwarded them to Cirro-Mazzoni, and they are now investigating. It would appear that there is certainly some bug in the firmware that needs some software 'pesticide' to eliminate, and hopefully C-M will find it and issue an update soon. Stay tuned!
Adrian, 5B4AIY